The conversation

Lessons learnedExperience excerpt · English

> I have multiple family members who have healthy memory, but can't accurately remember their email …

> I have multiple family members who have healthy memory, but can't accurately remember their email address everytime: the localpart, the domain, the syntax, everything. I got Gmail early enough that I have (my first name) dot (my last name) at gmail dot com. About twenty years ago, I started getting strange emails. At first I thought they were spam, because they were addressed to me by name but I had never joined those sites. Eventually I figured out that they were addressed to (my first name) (my last name) at gmail dot com. Which Gmail treats as the same address as the one with a dot in between. Since I had never ever given out a version of my email address without a dot in the middle, I eventually figured out that these emails were meant for someone else who shared the same first and last name as me. …

Original discussionLies We Tell Ourselves About Email Addresses189 source comments · at import
4

What was this responding to?

Parent context · original excerpt

FA

> It’s likely that more people out there are being filtered by badly-implemented form validation than there are being filtered by their own need of hand-holding. I wish this was asserted with evidence. The author might suggest this because they have unrealistic views of some users. > In the year of our lord 2026, you can reasonably expect your users to know how to type their own email address - or even better, auto-input from their OS, browser, keyboard app, or password manager. This really depends on who your users are. I have multiple family members who have healthy memory, but can't accurately remember their email address everytime: the localpart, the domain, the syntax, everything. Sending an email verification isn't sufficient, because if the user has typo'd ".com", they might never receive that email, and the user might never be back, or then have to escalate to support. Meanwhile,…

Full original

Community replies 0

No community replies yet. Add your perspective.

Replies from the source 4

Direct replies available in this import. Original-language excerpts.

JC

Randall estimates in the alt-text of https://xkcd.com/1279/ that there's about ¾ of a million people who just use somebody else's email on gmail without realizing it's not their email address.

Full original
SE

I also have first.last@gmail.com (which I don’t use anymore, and just keep around), I get all kinds of private mails. Contracts, invoices, confidential material, private photos. And of course, also automated signup mails, newsletters (which I make sure to block and report as spam, unsubscribing is a feature for newsletters that are opt-in), transactional mails etc. People really suck at knowing what their e-mail is. The private mails are down to 1/month, the others to ~3/week, but it used to be much higher for both categories. Oh and of course there is some kind of weird scam going on where spammers on German classifieds (Kleinanzeigen) send an e-mail to firstlast@gmail.com for whatever public first and last name of the lister is, and ask if the product is still available. No link, nothing. And all sent via gmail which has by an overwhelming majority become the biggest sender of spam for…

Full original
F_

> my name doppelganger must have registered firstnamelastname@yahoo.com, and then forgot the domain Alternative explanation: A hastily scribbled "@ymail.com" (along with its relative infrequency) can look to many people like "@gmail.com".

Full original
YC

Hey! Neat to see some more folks that have a story to tell about the oerhaps unintended side effects of the way the dot was implemented in gmail addresses. Reading these dot-related comments reminded me that I once made one here about how I was able to leverage this possibly asynchronous dot-handling at gmail. Because the story is a bittersweet sentimental one for me I had to go back and read it now, and though I am sitting here with bad allergies streaming down my face, it also felt really nice to remember that. I know this is a bit of a sideways comment, and I apologize for that but it isn't often I am overcome with emotion on HN, or on the topic of email addressing, and well, I appreciated the opportunity to re-read it now. Thanks. You might find my gmail dots story interesting too. It's a little long, but the dot-character portion begins about a third of the way down in my comment: …

Full original
Continue on Hacker News

Respect different perspectives. Share concrete experiences.

Sign in to post, reply, repost, and quote.