The conversation

Business & incomeExperience excerpt · English

TL;DR: We run multiple SaaS products on Stripe

TL;DR: We run multiple SaaS products on Stripe. Even with clear renewal reminders, invoices and easy cancellations, some users skip refunds and go straight to chargebacks. A $10 payment ended up costing us $43.95 recently. Banks almost always side with the cardholder, and the only reliable “win” I’ve seen is when the customer withdraws the dispute themselves. So here’s my question to the community: What’s really going on here? Why do banks completely ignore the terms customers agreed to when they subscribed, or even in cases where the claims are obviously false? And why aren’t customers required to provide any proof at all? What actually prevents someone from using a SaaS product, filing chargebacks every time they cancel, and essentially getting refunded for the last several months of usage? Would love to hear your thoughts.

Original discussionThe madness of SaaS chargebacks112 source comments · at import
8

Community replies 0

No community replies yet. Add your perspective.

Replies from the source 8

Direct replies available in this import. Original-language excerpts.

CS

Just consider it cost of doing business and move on. You can also offer discounts for alternative payment methods but something tells me cards will be more attractive.

Full original
GI

This could also be from fraud. Card testing for example, where they aim to figure out missing card details. Or some other nefarious use of stolen card details.

Full original
WH

Seems like banks and payment networks are incentivized to make it simple to collect all those chargeback fees.

Full original
AR

The credit card business of banks wants customers to spend money so they earn transaction fees. Everything the bank does is in service of this goal. Making it harder to do chargebacks would measurably reduce the transaction fees they earn in aggregate. Your SaaS is a dime a dozen to them. They dont care about you. You dont make them any money, especially when the customer is actively trying to stop doing business with you.

Full original
BL

> What’s really going on here? Why do banks completely ignore the terms customers agreed to when they subscribed, or even in cases where the claims are obviously false? And why aren’t customers required to provide any proof at all? they have a banking relationship with their client, and none whatsoever with you if they decline the chargeback they then take on a load of risk (they might lose their client, they might get reported to the regulator, they might be sued by their client and then stuck with the bill) but if they just pass it on then you take all the pain not surprising at all given the structure of how credit card payments work

Full original
MS

The bank most likely does not ignore them as such, it’s more that they are superseded by the credit card merchant agreement.

Full original
IL

I assume if you are running multiple SaaS you already discovered this - but the expectation is that you will amortize the cost of a chargeback into your price if you are a legit business. Card-not-present (I.E. internet transaction) has a lot more merchant fraud then friendly fraud (what we call these cases) and the incentives for both merchants and banks is to make sure the customer never loses trust in the system. If people were afraid to use their cards on the internet everyone loses. It doesn't make sense for both the merchants and the banks to arbitrate every 10$ transaction. I doubt your case even reached a human, or if it did they even gave it a minute of thought - you are just someone who does not know the rules to them. Now if a customer abuses the chargeback mechanism, he'll have is card revoked, probably be blacklisted and his life would be an insane amount of complicated from…

Full original
TO

My niche SaaS (monthly subs, no annual) gets about 1 or 2 chargebacks a year. I give instant refunds, we are very lenient with our terms, and I've made the unsubscribe flow 2 clicks from email or dashboard (want to cancel? click. Are you sure? click. Done. Confirmation email). Every subscription email also includes short instructions on cancellation. Even with a very customer friendly posture, the chargebacks fall into three categories: - bad experiences with other companies, so instant chargeback instead of emailing or calling - miscommunication between customer departments (accounting doesn't know about the subscription and chargeback) - fraud or lying about usage We've won about 50% of the chargebacks disputes. I recently added an admin interface that has a chargeback defense function that compiles evidence into a handy package I can upload to Stripe to dispute.

Full original
Continue on Hacker News

Respect different perspectives. Share concrete experiences.

Sign in to post, reply, repost, and quote.