The conversation

Lessons learnedExperience excerpt · English

I used to live in a country who is also a customer of GFW

I used to live in a country who is also a customer of GFW. Before v2ray came out, I had figured out devising any random protocol would defeat it. I would pass my SSH connecting used for socks5 through ROT13 or any ROTn, then the firewall won't gradually slow it down towards total stall after a few kilobytes. OpenSSH yells its name and version in plain text upon connection. A few years later (still before v2ray) they got more aggressive: Unknown protocols were stalled after a few kilobytes. I then learned if I pretend I'm doing something legitimate (!) such as downloading favicon.ico within a proper HTTP channel, they won't touch my "packets" (the favicon content was my packet). I think there was also a Iodine project doing the same with ping packets but it was slower than favicon-as-packets for me. Today I see v2ray has taken it to the maximum extent, suggesting valid web page front for an IP, valid https certificates, etc. When I started making money I was thinking about renting many IPs and send my traffic as round-robin to them as the detection relied heavily on IP consistency. …

Original discussionGeedge and MESA leak: Analyzing the great firewall’s largest document leak137 source comments · at import
2

What was this responding to?

Parent context · original excerpt

YO

https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/chinas-great-fire... https://x.com/gfw_report/status/1966669581302309018

Full original

Community replies 0

No community replies yet. Add your perspective.

Replies from the source 2

Direct replies available in this import. Original-language excerpts.

HI

From my own personal experience with an outline server running on the same IP over 3 years, the GFW consistently ends up blocking it around 3 days after I first connect. Outline does use shadowsocks to obfuscate but I suspect the traffic detection is what triggers it after 3 days of observations. Running multiple servers and repeatedly cycling through them is an experiment I want to try the next time I'm there. I've also observed similar behavior with the vpn I'm using as backup where the server I'm using tends to get blocked in around the same timeframe. It's using openvpn/wireguard as the underlying protocol which doesn't try to obfuscate itself so I suspect traffic pattern analysis plays a larger role in what gets blocked than the protocol itself. The exception was my recent trip week-long trip where I was mostly cycling between two servers without noticing either being blocked.

Full original
CO

> I would pass my SSH connecting used for socks5 through ROT13 or any ROTn, then the firewall won't gradually slow it down towards total stall after a few kilobytes. OpenSSH yells its name and version in plain text upon connection. Could you elaborate on that more? I'd love to dig into an implementation that does this, in case you still have the tools/scripts/programs available. I'm asking because for the last couple years I've been on and off working on my warps [1] soft router prototype which aims to hide in plain sight using exfil network protocols. (Think of it like DNS/HTTP smuggling but with the idea to use similar techniques in other network protocols, too) [1] https://github.com/tholian-network/warps

Full original
Continue on Hacker News

Respect different perspectives. Share concrete experiences.

Sign in to post, reply, repost, and quote.