The conversation

Lessons learnedExperience excerpt · English

I'm employed right now, for about 1 and half years, but there was a time that I tried to switch …

… I'm employed right now, for about 1 and half years, but there was a time that I tried to switch path from Web/Mobile developer to full backend developer, and in this attempt I got a job interview for a digital bank; I had everything checked out and expected to continue to step 2, even a friend of mine who works there thought I'd pass the process easily, but to our surprise, I didn't make it to the next step, and when I asked the interviewer for feedback they gave me a bullet list with just one bullet saying that I didn't "explore business logic much"! It didn't make any sense! I found it preposterous and insulting, to say the least. When I ask for feedback, I want to know what are you looking for and why I wasn't compatible with your position.

Original discussionThe developer job market is insane260 source comments · at import
2

What was this responding to?

Parent context · original excerpt

MI

The hiring process has been like this for a long time. I had a hiatus from work in 2016 and when I tried to get back to the job market it was impossible to find anything, even when I was over qualified for many of the positions I applied to and was even willing to take a considerable pay cut just because I was switching business domains (although the stack and many of the required soft skills to do the job remain the same) The vast majority of the interviewers I faced had no idea what they were doing or trying to measure. Loop interviews were the worst because it generally takes just one guy out out five to dislike you even if you had a great time with the other four. I mean I bet most of these guys in loop interviews would not even hire themselves It became so dreadful and time consuming that I had to tell recruiters right away I would not be doing any whiteboarding or solving puzzles. …

Full original

Community replies 0

No community replies yet. Add your perspective.

Replies from the source 2

Direct replies available in this import. Original-language excerpts.

YU

That's standard. Honest feedback can get them in legal trouble. Making up a BS reason is expected if somebody's personality was really off-putting. Nobody is ever going to give you honest feedback about that.

Full original
AR

It's more or less impossible to review non-trivial code without feedback from the author (i.e. have a conversation) outside of cases where it's just truly obviously awful. Often stuff just gets rejected for "I wouldn't have written it like this". Okay, fine; but that doesn't mean I can't write it like that. But if I don't know what you want... The reason people don't give concrete feedback is because there often just isn't a clear one beyond "I don't like it".

Full original
Continue on Hacker News

Respect different perspectives. Share concrete experiences.

Sign in to post, reply, repost, and quote.