The conversation

Business & incomeExperience excerpt · English

The proper way to fix the housing crisis is to allow the population to decrease, or for people to …

… The proper way to fix the housing crisis is to allow the population to decrease, or for people to not live as long (which also increases house demand). However that causes structural problems to the economy (see Japan). Edit: that is tongue-in cheek. In New Zealand, one major problem is that property is a better investment than a business. I made more money by owning two properties than by owning a moderately successful business over the last few years. New Zealand lacks a capital gains tax if you own a home for more than ten years, so the taxation advantage of property is huge compared to investing in any business. Wealthy New Zealanders invest in multiple properties because our government sets the incentives for property, and our government relatively penalises business owners or investors.

Original discussionThe High Cost of Expensive Housing (and How Auckland Fixed It)126 source comments · at import
2

Community replies 0

No community replies yet. Add your perspective.

Replies from the source 2

Direct replies available in this import. Original-language excerpts.

JA

1, 3 and 4, yes. 2... I disagree with, in the sense that you should still try to reduce the gap and we arent doing enough. You can make it less attractive to own multiple homes or curb airbnb etc to somewhat alleviate supply issues. It is not a panacea but you can reduce the issue.

Full original
MJ

> New York ain’t cheap even with high density housing. This wasn’t true in the 50s. Sure a single family townhome in the West Village will always be expensive, but it was possible for people to own 3-bedroom apartments within a 20 minute train ride from work on a median salary 60 years ago. And this was back when Manhattan had more people living there than do today. NYC made zoning choices that reduced the city’s density, and made building even the same kind of dense housing that was built in the 20s and 40s essentially illegal with zoning laws passed in the 60s. Neighborhoods like Park Slope and the West Village have a ton of demand, but a 2-story single family townhome cannot legally be built into a 6-family 6-story condo building in most cases. That’s what this article is arguing: zoning laws prevent new housing costs from dropping to be near a floor of (cost of land + cost of buildin…

Full original
Continue on Hacker News

Respect different perspectives. Share concrete experiences.

Sign in to post, reply, repost, and quote.